Skip to main content
by learnformula
Explore courses
search
For Business
Team license & compliance management
For Higher Education
Academic partnerships
For Government Agencies
Government training solutions
For Instructors & Course Creators
Teach on our marketplace
Become a Sponsor
Reach professionals where they learn
Log inStart 7-Day Free TrialStart Free TrialStart Free Trial
search
Explore courses
arrow_backBack to Latest Intelligence

Five Years of Small Business Restructuring: What ASIC's Report 847 Reveals About Rescue Outcomes and the Growing Tax Liability Problem

Darby Taylor•Nov 16, 2026•
7 min read
Share
SIGN UP AND GET
10% OFF
Sign up for our newsletter and get 10% off your next purchase!
By subscribing, I agree to LearnFormula's email marketing. I can unsubscribe anytime. See Privacy Policy.

For many struggling small businesses, the most dangerous moment is not the day revenue falls, but the day an unpaid tax bill becomes the largest debt on the books. After five years of operation, Australia's small business restructuring regime has given thousands of companies a structured way to survive that moment. ASIC's Report 847 shows the regime is largely working, yet it also flags a trend that should concern every accounting professional who advises a business in distress: tax-related liabilities are becoming more concentrated within restructuring outcomes. For practitioners, that is the real story.

This article draws on ASIC's media release on the review and its summary of Report 847. The full report contains the detailed data, so practitioners should read it directly before relying on any figures.

What the Small Business Restructuring Regime Is

The small business restructuring process was introduced to give eligible companies a faster, less costly alternative to traditional external administration. The model is built around debtor-in-possession principles: directors generally remain in control of the business while a restructuring practitioner is appointed to assist with developing and running a restructuring plan. The aim is to preserve viable businesses and jobs, rather than default to liquidation whenever financial pressure arises.

Eligibility is limited to companies that meet the statutory thresholds, principally a cap on total liabilities. That restriction matters, because it means the regime is designed for the owner-managed businesses that make up the bulk of Australia's accounting client base, not for larger enterprises.

What Report 847 Tells Us

According to ASIC's summary, Report 847 examines five years of the regime and finds positive outcomes for participating companies. The review's headline message is that the process is achieving its purpose for a meaningful share of businesses that use it. That is an important finding for a regime that has been criticised, in some quarters, as either too generous to directors or too easily used to defer debts owed to creditors.

The review also identifies a counterweight. Tax-related liabilities are becoming more concentrated in the debts being dealt with through restructuring. In practical terms, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is occupying a larger proportion of the debt pool in these matters, which changes the negotiating dynamics for everyone involved.

The regime is delivering for many businesses, but the growing weight of tax debts within restructuring outcomes is a signal that practitioners and advisers cannot treat tax as a secondary issue.

Why the Tax Concentration Matters

Tax debts behave differently from trade creditor debts. Unpaid PAYG withholding, superannuation guarantee shortfalls and GST amounts can accumulate quickly, and they often sit at the centre of the financial distress. Tax liabilities also carry statutory consequences that trade creditors do not, including director penalty exposure for certain unpaid amounts. A restructuring plan that fails to address the tax position adequately can leave the company and its directors exposed to the same enforcement pressure that prompted the restructuring in the first place.

The table below compares how the restructuring pathway differs from traditional administration on the points accountants most often raise with clients.

ConsiderationSmall Business RestructuringTraditional Administration
Control of the businessDirectors generally remain in control, with a restructuring practitioner assistingAn external administrator takes control of the company's affairs
EligibilityLimited to companies under the statutory liability thresholdGenerally available without the same size restriction
Plan approvalCreditors vote on a restructuring plan to compromise debtsCreditors' meetings determine the path, such as a deed of company arrangement or liquidation
Role of tax debtsTax creditors must be dealt with in the plan, and their concentration affects feasibilityTax claims are handled within the wider administration process
Typical advisory focusEarly engagement, cash flow forecasting, plan feasibilityInsolvency investigation, asset realisation, creditor returns

Practical Implications for Accounting Professionals

Report 847 is not only relevant to insolvency specialists. Most small business restructurings begin with a call to a client's accountant, bookkeeper or tax agent. That makes the general practitioner a critical early-warning point. Consider the following priorities:

  1. Identify distress early. Watch for lagging BAS and PAYG lodgements, unpaid superannuation, and payment plan requests to the ATO. These are often the first signals that a restructuring conversation is needed.
  2. Model the tax position properly. Any restructuring plan will need to address the ATO debt in a credible way. Build cash flow forecasts that show how tax liabilities will be met over the life of the plan.
  3. Assess director exposure. Directors of companies with unpaid withholding and superannuation obligations face personal risk. Advisers should make sure clients understand these obligations before any restructuring decision is taken.
  4. Test plan feasibility. A plan that compromises trade creditors but leaves a large tax debt unresolved may not be sustainable. Stress-test the forecast against realistic ATO payment arrangements.
  5. Coordinate with specialists. Restructuring practitioners, lawyers and ATO collection teams each play distinct roles. Early coordination reduces the risk of a plan collapsing under competing pressures.
Key TakeawayThe restructuring regime works best when it starts early. For accountants, the tax position is the test of whether a rescue plan is credible, so tax analysis should be the first step in any distressed-client conversation, not an afterthought.

The Road Ahead for Advisers

ASIC's findings point to a regime that has earned its place in the insolvency landscape, but one whose success depends on the quality of advice given before formal processes begin. As tax debts represent a growing share of restructuring outcomes, the profession's role in early intervention becomes more significant. Accounting practices that build distress-detection processes, strengthen their tax and cash flow forecasting capability, and maintain clear working relationships with restructuring practitioners will be best placed to help clients survive difficult periods.

Practitioners should read the full ASIC release and Report 847 to understand the detailed data behind these trends. Over the coming years, the critical question will be whether early advice can keep tax debts manageable enough for restructuring to fulfil its promise, and whether the profession is ready to lead that conversation.