Every HR leader has heard some version of the same complaint: an employee insists they worked more hours than the timesheet shows. Usually the dispute ends with a manager's recollection against a payroll record. A recent U.S. Department of Labor opinion letter, reported by HR Dive, changes the stakes of that argument. It clarifies that work performed remotely outside scheduled hours and travel between job sites must count toward Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) service eligibility. It also signals that when employers fail to keep accurate hour logs, eligibility may legally be presumed in the employee's favor.
For HR, this is not a narrow technical footnote. It affects who qualifies for job-protected leave, how leave requests are adjudicated, and how defensible your timekeeping practices really are.
What the Opinion Letter Clarifies
FMLA eligibility rests on two core tests. An employee must have worked for the employer for at least 12 months, and must have worked at least 1,250 hours during the 12 months before the leave begins. The hours test is where recordkeeping gaps become costly. Many employees, particularly those with remote, field, or mobile roles, do work that never appears on a clock-in record.
The opinion letter addresses two categories of uncaptured time:
- Remote work performed outside scheduled hours, such as answering email in the evening, finishing reports on a weekend, or handling urgent requests from home.
- Travel time between job sites, which many employers treat as unpaid commuting even when the employee is performing work-related travel for the employer.
Under the DOL's reading, these hours are not excluded simply because they fall outside a standard schedule or were not formally logged. Counting them can push an employee over the 1,250-hour threshold and into FMLA coverage they might otherwise have been denied.
The practical question is no longer only whether an employee can prove the hours. It is whether the employer can prove they were not worked.
The Presumption Problem
The most consequential element of the guidance is its treatment of missing records. When an employer does not maintain accurate hour logs, the DOL's position indicates that eligibility may be presumed in the employee's favor. In other words, a gap in your documentation can become your liability.
This shifts the evidentiary burden in a way many organizations have not planned for. Consider how a typical eligibility dispute unfolds today:
- An employee requests leave and claims they have met the hours requirement.
- HR checks the timekeeping system, which shows fewer than 1,250 hours.
- The employee presents evidence of after-hours emails, texts, or travel logs.
- If the employer's records cannot rebut that evidence, the employer's denial becomes difficult to defend.
Where the Exposure Concentrates
Not every workforce carries equal risk. The highest exposure typically sits with employees whose work blends into personal time or moves across locations. The table below outlines common scenarios and the HR response each one calls for.
| Work Scenario | Why It Matters for FMLA Eligibility | Recommended HR Response |
|---|---|---|
| Remote employees checking email after hours | Unlogged work may count toward the 1,250-hour test | Clarify whether after-hours work is expected, and require capture through approved systems |
| Field technicians and sales staff traveling between sites | Travel time performed for the employer may be countable hours | Audit how travel time is coded and reconcile against job-site assignments |
| Exempt salaried staff without hour tracking | Hours are often not recorded at all, leaving eligibility unverifiable | Implement lightweight time capture or periodic hour reconstruction for FMLA purposes |
| Hourly staff with rounding or off-the-clock edits | Altered or rounded records may undermine the employer's presumption of accuracy | Review rounding practices and edit trails for consistency with wage-and-hour rules |
Note that this guidance intersects with wage-and-hour compliance. Any practice that undercounts hours for FMLA purposes may also raise questions under the Fair Labor Standards Act, since unrecorded work time can create unpaid overtime exposure. HR should treat these as a single problem rather than two separate audits.
Building Defensible Hour Records
The good news is that the fix is largely procedural. Organizations that have already invested in time and attendance systems can strengthen them with a few targeted changes.
Practical Steps for the Next 90 Days
- Map remote and mobile work patterns. Identify which roles routinely perform work outside scheduled hours or during travel, and document how that work is captured.
- Define what counts as work time. Publish a clear policy on after-hours communication, remote work logging, and travel time, and make sure managers understand it.
- Create a correction pathway. Give employees a simple way to report unlogged hours, and require managers to review and approve corrections promptly.
- Audit FMLA eligibility determinations. Revisit recent denials where hours were calculated from timekeeping data alone, especially for remote and field populations.
- Coordinate with legal counsel. Align FMLA eligibility procedures with wage-and-hour recordkeeping obligations and state leave laws, some of which set their own eligibility rules.
Avoid the Opposite Mistake
Some HR teams will be tempted to respond by aggressively reconstructing hours after an employee requests leave. That approach carries its own risk. Retroactive estimates that appear self-serving can damage credibility with both employees and regulators. The stronger position is consistent, contemporaneous capture that applies to every employee in similar roles.
The Broader Context: Work Is Harder to Measure
This guidance arrives amid a wider shift in how work is performed and recorded. A separate HR Dive report on near-instant candidate rejections found that three-quarters of rejected applicants doubt any human reviewed their submission. Automation is changing how employers evaluate candidates, and it is also changing how employees experience their own workloads. Work increasingly happens in messaging apps, on laptops at night, and in the gaps between meetings. Systems designed for a nine-to-five model are struggling to keep up.
The same pressure appears in global talent decisions. Reporting on whether more companies will end their H-1B visa programs describes employers weighing rising compliance burdens against the risk of losing specialized talent. In both cases, HR is being asked to demonstrate precise, defensible records in environments that resist precision.
Retirement benefits reflect a similar compliance tightening. The IRS has finalized automatic enrollment guidelines under SECURE 2.0, requiring qualifying 401(k) and 403(b) plans to enroll newly eligible employees at an initial contribution rate of at least 3%, with annual escalation thresholds to follow. Plan administrators will need reliable data on who is eligible and when, which makes accurate eligibility records a shared priority across benefits and leave administration.
What HR Should Watch Next
Opinion letters are interpretive guidance rather than binding regulations, so their practical reach depends on how courts, employers, and agency investigators respond. Still, HR should assume that the DOL's position will shape enforcement expectations and employee advocacy. Plaintiffs' attorneys will look for unlogged hours, and agency investigators will ask how employers verified eligibility.
Over the coming year, expect closer scrutiny of remote-work monitoring, travel-time policies, and the consistency of timekeeping across departments. Leaders who treat this guidance as a prompt to modernize their hour records now will be far better positioned than those who wait for a denied leave request to reveal the gap.
