What if the cheapest way for a global AI developer to use Australian creative work was to never ask permission at all? That is the scenario former Australian Competition and Consumer Commission chair Rod Sims says the government must avoid. According to a report on his position, proposed copyright changes could turn Australia into an intellectual property tax haven for artificial intelligence developers.
The Tax Haven Warning
Sims's critique reframes the AI copyright debate. Rather than asking whether AI training on copyrighted material is lawful in principle, he is asking who pays, and who decides. His concern is that a statutory exception would transfer value from rights holders, including authors, journalists, musicians, photographers and publishers, to the developers who build commercial models on their work, without a price being set through negotiation or a court.
The phrase "tax haven" is deliberate. A jurisdiction with a low or zero effective levy attracts capital and activity that would otherwise be priced elsewhere. Applied to copyright, an exception would make Australia an attractive place to train models on local content, while the economic return for local creators would be reduced.
What Sims Is Asking Government to Do
Sims has put forward two alternatives to a statutory exception. The summary of his position identifies them as follows:
- Mandate commercial licensing: require AI developers to negotiate and pay for the use of copyright material in training.
- Rely on judicial resolution: leave contested questions to the courts to resolve under the existing framework, rather than legislating a broad carve-out in advance.
The core message is that Australia should not legislate an exception that hands AI developers the value of creative works before any bargain has been struck.
Both options preserve a market-based price signal. The first creates a clear commercial obligation; the second lets precedent develop case by case. Each treats copyright as a property right with economic content, not as a barrier to be removed.
Comparing the Policy Options
The table below sets out how the three broad approaches compare on the issues that matter most to practitioners advising rights holders, technology clients and government.
| Approach | Effect on AI developers | Effect on rights holders | Practical advice implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Statutory exception for AI training | Lower cost and legal certainty for training uses within scope | Reduced bargaining power; limited remedies | Contracts may need to contract out of or work around the exception |
| Mandated commercial licensing | Must negotiate and pay; higher compliance burden | Clear right to payment; stronger negotiating position | Demand for licensing, valuation and collective-management advice |
| Judicial resolution under existing law | Uncertain until precedent is set; litigation risk | Relies on case outcomes and litigation funding | Increased need for litigation strategy and evidence of use |
Why Australia's Fair Dealing Framework Matters
Australia's copyright regime does not contain a general fair use defence of the kind found in the United States. Instead, the Copyright Act 1968 provides specific fair dealing exceptions, such as research or study, criticism or review, parody and satire, and news reporting. Any AI-specific exception would be a deliberate and significant departure from this structure.
This is why the debate has drawn scrutiny from lawyers and policymakers alike. A narrow exception could be drafted carefully, but a broad one could reshape how the Act operates for every category of creative work. Sims's warning is effectively a warning about how far a single exception can travel.
Practical Implications for Australian Lawyers
Regardless of how the government responds, practitioners should prepare for a period of uncertainty. The following areas are likely to demand attention:
- Technology contracts: review AI vendor and licensing agreements for warranties on training data provenance, IP indemnities and allocation of infringement risk.
- Rights holder strategy: advise publishers, media companies and creators on licensing models, collective arrangements and evidence that their works have been used.
- Due diligence: assess whether acquisition targets rely on models trained on material they may not be entitled to use.
- Litigation readiness: prepare for test cases, which may depend on documentation of data sources and commercial terms.
- Policy engagement: submissions to government consultations will shape how any exception or licensing regime is drafted.
A Note on Timing
Because the reform remains proposed rather than enacted, the most valuable work right now is preparatory. Firms that build clear advice frameworks on data licensing and provenance will be better placed whichever path the government chooses.
Other Developments on the Legal Wire
Several other reports in the same news cycle illustrate the breadth of issues confronting the profession:
- NSW Supreme Court dismissed noteholders' challenge to Zen Energy's super senior debt. The court held that majority noteholder consent, rather than unanimity, was sufficient to issue super senior security. The judgment clarifies how negative pledge and intercreditor priority clauses operate, a lesson for anyone drafting or negotiating finance documents.
- The Fair Work Ombudsman has sued Lush Australasia Retail in the Federal Circuit and Family Court. The case is the regulator's first litigation under new laws prohibiting employers from advertising job vacancies with unlawfully low pay rates, and it signals active enforcement of the advertising provisions.
- The Federal Circuit and Family Court has appointed six new judges across Divisions 1 and 2, serving five registries nationally. The appointments followed an open expression-of-interest process.
- The High Court ordered a retrial in a civil damages claim by a former ward of the state against her deceased foster father's estate, finding that the NSW Court of Appeal erred in its treatment of the deceased's prior criminal convictions.
- FrontTier's Sam Shosanya argues sleep management should be treated as part of professional performance in law firms, not a purely private matter, given its effects on judgement and wellbeing.
- Corporate, banking and finance lawyers were recognised at the 10th annual Women in Finance Awards in Sydney.
Looking Ahead: Structure Will Decide Value
Sims's intervention matters because it locates the AI copyright question within competition and market design, not only intellectual property doctrine. If Australia chooses licensing or judicial resolution, it will build a market in which creators are paid for the use of their work. If it chooses a broad exception, it will make a policy decision in favour of developers at the expense of the creative sector, and the consequences will be felt in contracts, litigation and client advice for years.
For the profession, the next phase is about preparation. Lawyers who understand the economics of training data, the limits of Australia's fair dealing framework and the drafting consequences of licensing mandates will be best placed to advise clients whichever way the government moves.
