Skip to main content
by learnformula
Explore courses
search
For Business
Team license & compliance management
For Higher Education
Academic partnerships
For Government Agencies
Government training solutions
For Instructors & Course Creators
Teach on our marketplace
Become a Sponsor
Reach professionals where they learn
Log inStart 7-Day Free TrialStart Free TrialStart Free Trial
search
Explore courses
arrow_backBack to Latest Intelligence

Three Fixes for Lawful Access: What Michael Geist's Senate Testimony on Bill C-22 Means for Canadian Practice

Michael Trem•Nov 19, 2026•
8 min read
Share
SIGN UP AND GET
10% OFF
Sign up for our newsletter and get 10% off your next purchase!
By subscribing, I agree to LearnFormula's email marketing. I can unsubscribe anytime. See Privacy Policy.

Every text message, subscriber record, and connection log your client generates may soon sit in a telecommunications provider's storage for longer than most people expect, and the state may be able to reach it with less scrutiny than Canadian privacy law has traditionally required. That is the tension University of Ottawa law professor Michael Geist put before the Senate National Security Committee as it considers Bill C-22. His message was not opposition to lawful access as a concept. It was a call for three specific amendments that would, in his view, make the bill workable and constitutionally defensible.

The Core of the Testimony

Geist's presentation, as summarized in his own post, focused on three recommendations. Each targets a different pressure point in the proposed framework, and together they represent a coherent argument about where lawful access regimes tend to overreach.

  • A 30-day cap on mandatory metadata retention, so that providers cannot be required to hold subscriber and traffic metadata indefinitely.
  • Explicit protections against weakened encryption, so that lawful access obligations cannot be read as requiring providers to build backdoors or degrade the security of their services.
  • Higher evidentiary thresholds for accessing subscriber information, so that police and other authorities must meet a more demanding standard before obtaining identifying data tied to online activity.

For practitioners, the significance lies less in the novelty of any single point than in how they interact. Retention limits determine how much data exists to be searched. Encryption protections determine whether the data is readable at all. Access thresholds determine who gets to see it and on what showing. Adjust one lever without the others, and the regime shifts in ways that may not match Parliament's intent.

Why Subscriber Information Sits at the Centre

The threshold recommendation deserves particular attention because Canadian courts have already spoken to it. In R. v. Spencer, 2014 SCC 43, the Supreme Court of Canada held that subscriber information linked to internet activity can attract a reasonable expectation of privacy under section 8 of the Charter, and that police generally require a warrant to obtain it in that context. The Court's reasoning turned on the way subscriber data reveals the intimate details of a person's online life, not merely a name and address.

That background matters for the Senate's deliberations. A legislative framework that lowers the bar for subscriber access invites a fresh Charter challenge, and the evidentiary standard Geist proposes is, in effect, an attempt to align statutory language with the privacy values the Court has already articulated. Counsel reviewing any final text should map each access provision against the Spencer analysis rather than assuming that a statutory production power automatically satisfies section 8.

"Lawful access is only lawful if the safeguards are built into the statute rather than left to operational discretion." This principle, reflected in the thrust of Geist's three recommendations, should guide how practitioners read any final version of the bill.

Comparing the Proposals

The table below summarizes how each recommendation shifts the framework and who in practice is most affected. It is drawn from Geist's published position and is intended as a working reference rather than a reproduction of bill text.

Issue Geist's Proposed Fix Practical Impact for Counsel
Metadata retention 30-day cap on mandatory retention Limits the volume of historical data available to investigators; affects disclosure planning and preservation demands in criminal files
Encryption Explicit protection against weakened encryption Shapes the technical feasibility of compelled assistance; relevant to telecom compliance advice and to any argument about the reliability of decrypted evidence
Subscriber information Higher evidentiary threshold for access Determines the standard police must meet; directly engages Spencer and section 8 arguments in disclosure and suppression motions
Key Takeaway: The three amendments are interdependent. A long retention window paired with a low access threshold would create a large, easily reachable pool of identifying data, which is precisely the risk the Spencer analysis anticipated.

Practical Implications for Canadian Legal Professionals

Lawyers in several practice areas will feel the effects of how this debate resolves. The obligations and opportunities differ by role.

Criminal Defence and Crown Practice

Defence counsel should begin building familiarity with the mechanics of production orders, preservation demands, and metadata requests now, since the evidentiary threshold and retention period will determine what disclosure exists and what can be challenged. Crown counsel will need to document the basis for each access request carefully, because a higher threshold raises the stakes of any gap between the statutory test and the affidavit supporting it.

Privacy and Constitutional Litigation

Privacy practitioners should view the Senate process as an early opportunity to shape the record. Submissions that tie specific statutory language to the reasoning in Spencer are more likely to influence drafting than general objections to surveillance. Anticipating section 8 challenges at the drafting stage is far cheaper than defending a poorly framed statute later.

Telecommunications and Corporate Compliance

In-house counsel at telecommunications providers and technology companies should model the cost of retention obligations, the operational consequences of any encryption-related requirement, and the risk of conflicting obligations across jurisdictions. A 30-day cap, if adopted, would reshape data-governance policies. Its absence would require a different and likely more expensive compliance posture.

Policy and Government Advisory Work

Lawyers advising government or public-interest organizations should note that Geist's recommendations are specific and drafting-ready. Clear, measurable proposals are more persuasive to committee members than broad calls for caution, and the three fixes offer a template for how to frame amendments in future digital-security legislation.

  1. Review the current text of Bill C-22 against the Spencer framework for subscriber information.
  2. Model the operational and cost implications of a retention limit for your client base.
  3. Prepare submissions or client advice that addresses encryption obligations in concrete technical terms.
  4. Monitor committee amendments and the government's response, since final wording will control litigation outcomes.

What Comes Next

Parliamentary committees do not always adopt the amendments witnesses propose, and the government may resist limits on retention or access that it views as operationally necessary. Still, the framing Geist offers is likely to remain relevant regardless of the outcome. If the bill proceeds without these protections, the resulting challenges will turn on whether courts read the statute narrowly enough to preserve the privacy values Spencer recognized. If the Senate adopts some or all of the recommendations, practitioners will need to learn a new set of thresholds, timelines, and technical duties quickly.

The coming months will show whether lawful access in Canada is built around clear limits or around broad powers that depend on discretion. For lawyers, the practical task is to know the statutory text as well as the constitutional backdrop, and to be ready to argue either side of the line Parliament ultimately draws.